HOW UK POLICE FORCES POLICE ELECTRIC SCOOTERS

REVEALING THE TRUTH ABOUT THE POLICING OF E-SCOOTERS IN THE UK

Written by Ed Wiles, Scootered Founder

Key Points
  • Met Police seize 3x more scooters than others combined.
  • Many forces cannot say why e-scooters were seized.

  • Introduction

    After the death of YouTuber Emily Hartridge, when she collided with a lorry while riding an e-scooter in July 2019 (at a London roundabout where a cyclist had also been killed), the government announced a crackdown on e-scooters. It proved short-lived and restricted to London, but in 2020, police forces again warned against their use - despite hire schemes being trialled in various UK cities. The problem remains (as of January 2022) that e-scooters are classified as motor vehicles and, as they are not taxable, are therefore not legal to ride on public roads. Read more about the law on e-scooters. To see if police forces are implementing the law, I have been making FOI requests to UK police forces for data on e-scooter seizures and fines, and include the results below.


    Results

    The results show that many more police forces have been taking action against e-scooter riders recently, though forces in and around London still take the most action. Strikingly, the Met Police seem to be seizing three times as many e-scooters as all other polices forces combined. Worryingly, many forces struggle (or do not bother) to differentiate between seizures for contravening the Road Traffic Act and seizures for other reasons (eg if the scooter was stolen or used in a crime) so the results may often be an overestimate. For instance, West Yorkshire Police were only able to confirm three e-scooters were seized for contravening Road Traffic Act (I left it at that as their system is a mess), while Bedfordshire explained that they only seize e-scooters when there are "aggravating circumstances", such as "dangerous riding". Another caveat is that a police force can give a different answer to the same FOI request.


    Fines and Confiscations by Each Police Force

    Police Force
    Fines
    2019
    Seizures
    2019

    Fines
    2020
    Confiscations
    2020

    Fines
    2021
    Seizures
    2021

    Avon & Somerset

    UNAVAIL. 1 UNAVAIL. 4 UNAVAIL. 21
    Bedfordshire UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 1 UNAVAIL. 29
    Cambridgeshire UNAVAIL. 1 UNAVAIL. 4 UNAVAIL. 7
    Cheshire Constabulary UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL.
    City of London Police 0 12 0 2 0 65
    Cleveland Police UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 3
    Cumbria UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 2 UNAVAIL. 12
    Derbyshire Constabulary UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 11 UNAVAIL. 66
    Devon & Cornwall Police 0 0 0 4 0 82
    Dorset Police 0 0 0 0 3 47
    Durham Constabulary
    Essex Police UNAVAIL. 1 UNAVAIL. 38 UNAVAIL. 317
    Gloucestershire Constabulary 0 0        
    Greater Manchester
    Gwent Police UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 20 UNAVAIL. 31
    Hampshire Constabulary UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL.    
    Hertfordshire 0 0 0 15 UNAVAIL. 38
    Humberside Police UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 10 2 25 *
    Kent Police 0 0 10 5 50 71
    Lancashire Constabulary 13 59
    Leicestershire Police UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 6 UNAVAIL. 58
    Lincolnshire Police 0 0 UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL.
    Merseyside
    Metropolitan Police Service UNAVAIL. 54 UNAVAIL. 284 UNAVAIL. 4001
    Norfolk Constabulary UNAVAIL. 1 ** UNAVAIL. 12 21 181
    North Wales Police UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL.   UNAVAIL.  12
    North Yorkshire UNAVAIL. UNAVIAL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. 1
    Northamptonshire 0 0 0 12    
    Northumbria Police UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 18
    Nottinghamshire Police UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL.
    Police Scotland UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL.
    South Yorkshire 0 UNAVAIL. 0 3    
    South Wales Police 0 0        
    Staffordshire 0 0 0 0 17 31
    Suffolk Constabulary UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 9 24 126
    Surrey Police UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 12 UNAVAIL. 75
    Sussex Police 0  

    0
        22 98
    Thames Valley UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL. UNAVAIL.    
    Warwickshire Police 0 0 1 10 5 25
    West Mercia Police 0 0 0 4    
    West Midlands Police

    UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 0    
    West Yorkshire Police UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 20 UNAVAIL. 3 ***
    Wiltshire Police

    UNAVAIL. 0 UNAVAIL. 5 UNAVAIL. 16
    TOTAL 0 69 11 471 142 5422
    * Humberside warn some seizures may relate to mobility scooters. ** Norfolk reported an "adapted child's scooter" being seized for not having insurance. I include this as an e-scooter. *** More reported but only three recorded for contravening Road Traffic Act, meaning others could have been seized in connection with robberies etc.

    Recovering Your Electric Scooter

    Police forces should be taking scooters seized under laws regarding "motor vehicles" to their vehicle recovery units (eg Charlton or Perivale in London), where owners can retrieve their scooters for a fee (the Met charges £150 plus £10 for every day). However, I have heard that police forces are failing to inform owners of their rights and/or refusing to release scooters. I believe this to be illegal: unlike a car, an e-scooter can be carried away and the police would thus seem to have no legal right to refuse returning it to the owner.


    Confiscations By Metropolitan Police Per Month in 2021 (results since 2019)
    Month (2021)

    Confiscations

    January 103
    February 133
    March 190
    April 174
    May 361
    June 1103
    July 511
    August 398
    September 416
    October 262
    November 280
    December 70
    Total 4001